Saturday, June 14, 2025

Automated Infringement

This is the weekly dispatch from Bizarro Studios North, where I have been writing and drawing the Monday through Saturday Bizarro comics since 2018. My partner and friend Dan Piraro created Bizarro in the late twentieth century and continues to do the Sunday comic from Rancho Bizarro in Mexico.

Wayno 



I had my first serious encounter with AI thievery this week, in a smaller echo of the recent wholesale counterfeiting of multiple editorial cartoonists.

A sharp-eyed reader contacted Dan Piraro to alert us to an online ad for a plumbing company in Louisiana. The ad used one of my Bizarro gags, that had been fed into some AI platform and redrawn in a bland, soulless style, with no accreditation to the original source. The colors and staging were the same as my original panel, and the dialogue was identical. It was clearly a copy.

We brought the fakery to the attention of our editors at King Features and they forwarded it to the appropriate legal watchdogs. Apparently, they did their job, because the bogus Bizarro cartoon has disappeared, at least from the place where we saw it.

Coincidentally, the topic of using AI to "assist" artists came up recently on the local illustrators' group's online forum. A member had fed a photo of a painting in progress to an AI platform to see how it would describe the work.

I was among the respondents, and did my best to articulate my disdain for doing anything to further enable the harvesting of human creativity.

Colleagues, please think twice before inputting anything you created into an AI app. Everything you feed it is used for its "training."

I just learned about someone who prompted AI to "redraw" one of my cartoons and used it as an ad for their business. It's definitely copied from my work but dumbed down into a bland, generic "style." With no accreditation, of course.
 

I'd share the two images for you to compare them side-by-side, but that would only spread more copies of the counterfeit. Feeding any AI platform work that you created, even once, just out of curiosity, is harmful to yourself and your peers.

Beyond its ability to facilitate theft from artists, AI is a serious environmental threat due to its insane energy requirements.

Sorry to get all lecture-y. I realize that a lot of AI is nearly unavoidable since it's embedded in almost everything we use. I don't mean to be a scold, but it's coming after all of us, and I hope we don't put out the welcome mat for it!

Here's a well-reasoned essay on the topic that does a much better job than I could. And it was written by a human.

Multiple members of the forum offered their opinions in a lively and respectful discussion on the topic. One participant seemed a little too defensive about resisting AI, which made me wonder how much they might be relying on it to assist or enhance their work. But I'm of a naturally suspicious nature, so who knows.

No doubt the debate will continue for a long time to come, assuming the world isn't burnt to a lump of smoldering coal in the near future.



Today's historical pipe pic comes to us from a Bizarro reader from Nipomo, CA (the same location as last week's contributor!)



I'll leave it to our correspondent to elaborate:
My grandfather, D. H. Wulzen Jr., was a pharmacist in San Francisco who became interested in photography beginning about 1897. He left over a thousand glass plate negatives when he passed, and my father (who became a commercial photographer) spent considerable time in his later years making prints and donating the best work to various collections. 

The original plate of this shot now resides in the San Francisco Historical Society collections at the SF Public Library. Like his acquaintance, Arnold Genthe, DHW spent time in SF's Chinatown and took many memorable photos of the people and built environment. 

The man pictured here is probably taking a break from his work in the basement restaurant that is behind him. The SF library mentions that this is an opium pipe, but [that is] not so, as opium pipes have different unique characteristics. This is just a guy on his smoke break. We don't have a specific date on this one, but all of the Chinatown photos were taken in 1900 and 1901, so [it was] well before the 1906 earthquake and fire.

Thanks for the fascinating backstory to this museum-worthy photo.



I was recently approached by a company that sells CBD gummies named after a famous stoner comedy duo, and offered a "social media collaboration opportunity" to promote their product on my Insta in exchange for some chewable samples.


Unfortunately, my system can't handle CBD (and forget about THC), so I declined, and, as always, these gags were created by a human cartoonist, without the influence of artificial intelligence or drugs.


Best of all, the pharmacy the fills the prescription accepts Monopoly money.

A colleague who saw this cartoon asked me what cursive sounds like, and I can't stop wondering about it myself.

When the criminals were arrested, Variety's agricultural edition ran the headline, Fake Fungi Fools Farmstand Frequenters.

Thursday's panel was almost a Tarzan gag captioned Man of the Loincloth, but I came to my senses.

Bizarro celebrated Father's Day a bit early this year.

The week ended with that beloved Italian cartoon character, Prosciutto Porco.


Thanks for reading this far down into the post. You're almost done, and I appreciate your eyeballs. See you next week with more visual and verbal shenanigans.



Bonus Track

Groucho Marx: "Father's Day"
Decca Records, 1957


Happy Father's Day to all the dads reading the blog, whether your children are human, feline, canine, or otherwise.



A Bounty of Bizarro Bits & Bobs

If you like what we do and appreciate that it's free, we encourage you to explore the following links.


   

14 comments:

  1. Wayno -

    Having read your commentary on AI, plagiarism, and copyright infringement, I thought sure you'd reference the suit brought this week from some big players in the industries...

    The headline reads:
    "Disney and Universal sue AI firm Midjourney for copyright infringement"

    For those interested in doing a deeper dive into this, you can read the full article here:

    https://apnews.com/article/disney-universal-midjourney-copyright-lawsuit-722b1b892192e7e1628f7ae5da8cc427

    I wonder if the case will be a battle of AI lawyers in front of a potentially biased AI judge? Hmmm...

    Best,
    David R.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, David. I was peripherally aware of that suit, and I like your speculation about how it'll play out.

      Delete
    2. Michael Johnson1:23 AM

      Regarding AI, it appears (per a substack by North Carolina Attorney General Jeff Jackson) that buried in the Big Beautiful Bill is language forbidding states to pass or enforce laws that affect the development of AI. For 10 years. That means you and I are on our own.

      Delete
    3. Michael, It's amazing how much crap they stuffed into that big, bloated bucket of bull.

      Delete
  2. Anonymous7:11 PM

    My husband likes Bizarro though is not a big fan like I am. However, he absolutely loved the Foragery cartoon!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for letting me know! Happy to hear!

      Delete
  3. Anonymous11:46 PM

    They are already beta testing the AI replacement for the FlushMe app

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous10:22 AM

    Groucho — such a cornball! I love him! (BTW, find his “Captain Spaulding song somewhere — it’s even cornier than this one!)
    — Dave J.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep! Not to mention "Lydia the Tattooed Lady."

      Delete
  5. Anonymous5:13 PM

    Monday’s placebo ‘toon brought me back to one from 2012 ( 2/22/2012 to be exact). “Yes, we carry placebos, but you’ll need a fake prescription.”

    As to your commentary on AI, I am completely in agreement with you, for the most part. AI-generated “art” is clearly theft of the original artists works, even if the end result is a conglomeration of same. Maybe even more so.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha! I had to look up the 2/22/12 gag, and you're right on. Great minds??? Thanks for the comment!


      Delete
  6. Artificial intelligence has been around for forever under the guise of politicians!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True, Lee, and it's being quickly replaced by Actual Ignorance.

      Delete